The resignation letter of the former NSW building commissioner has been referred to the state’s corruption watchdog following questions about why he abruptly quit last month.
Key points:
The NSW Opposition compelled the government to make the resignation letter public within 24 hours
Premier Dominic Perrottet revealed the letter had also been referred to ICAC
The building commissioner worked closely with former cabinet minister Eleni Petinos
Pressure has been building on the NSW government to make David Chandler’s letter public after reports he may have resigned because of a strained relationship with former fair trading minister Eleni Petinos.
Ms Petinos was sacked from the NSW ministry last month over bullying allegations, which she denies.
Premier Dominic Perrottet today revealed in parliament that Mr Chandler’s resignation letter had been referred to the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC).
Mr Perrottet was pressed during question time about whether the former commissioner’s resignation had anything to do with Ms Petinos.
“Do you stand by your statements of yesterday that the sacking of [Ms Petinos] had nothing to do with the resignation of David Chandler?” Opposition Leader Chris Minns asked.
“Yes,” Mr Perrottet answered.
Since Mr Chandler quit last month, citing the need for a “reset”, the Opposition has been calling for his resignation letter to be made public.
Today Labor successfully moved a motion in the upper house to compel the government to produce the letter within 24 hours.
Yesterday Mr Perrottet said he had not read the letter, but now he says he has.
“I have read the resignation letter from David Chandler to the DCS (Department of Customer Service) Secretary Emma Hogan.”
“Out of an abundance of caution, the letter was provided to the ICAC for information.
“I understand the letter is to be provided to the upper house tomorrow.”
The Premier was also pressed on when he learned that the letter had been referred to the ICAC.
“Late last night,” Mr Perrottet replied.
Labor’s move to compel the government to release the document comes after it was revealed Ms Petinos met with a property developer linked to former deputy premier John Barilaro earlier this year.
After the two meetings on June 2 and June 21, a building ban affecting the developer, Coronation Property, was lifted.
Ms Petinos said the lifting of that ban had nothing to do with her and would have been a decision made by Mr Chandler.
Mr Chandler was appointed as the state’s first building commissioner by former premier Gladys Berejiklian in 2019 to clean up the building industry.
An internal review into John Barilaro’s controversial appointment to a lucrative trade role in New York has cost taxpayers $73,000 and is overdue.
Key points:
An internal review into Mr Barilaro’s appointment has cost taxpayers $73,500
The Premier has received part of a draft section of the report
Mr Barilaro will reappear before a parliamentary inquiry on Friday
The former NSW Public Service Commissioner Graeme Head was asked to conduct the review after it was ordered by Premier Dominic Perrottet last month.
New documents have been released publicly through a parliamentary order revealing that the fee set for the review was $73,500.
The documents suggest that when Mr Head was first engaged in late June the completion date was set at July 15, which gave the former Commissioner three weeks to undertake it.
But another document reveals it was extended to August 5.
The review is understood to be funded by the Department of Premier and Cabinet.
In the new tranche of documents, there is also the official letter from the Secretary of the Department Michael Coutts-Trotter to Mr Head which sets out the terms of reference.
It includes inquiring into “details and outcomes of all recruitment and selection processes that were commenced in relation to the role of Senior Trade and Investment Commissioner to the Americas”.
Mr Coutts-Trotter added “including arrangements for managing actual and perceived conflicts of interest” in the letter.
The Premier has received part of a draft section of the report which prompted him to force trade minister Stuart Ayres to resign last week.
At the time, Mr Perrottet said the draft section raised concerns that Mr Ayres had breached the Ministerial Code of Conduct but it wasn’t in the remit of Mr Head’s review to investigate if such a breach had occurred.
Yesterday the Premier asked for Bruce McClintock, SC, to conduct a legal review into whether there was a breach of the code.
Mr Perrottet has promised to make both the reviews public once he receives them.
Mr Barilaro has withdrawn from taking the New York job.
The former deputy premier told a parliamentary inquiry on Monday that he had been interviewed as part of the Head review.
Mr Barilaro will reappear before the parliamentary inquiry investigating his appointment on Friday.
Former NSW deputy premier John Barilaro has told an inquiry he wishes he did not apply for a lucrative New York role he was controversially awarded, describing the process as a “s**tshow”.
Mr Barilaro is giving evidence for the first time to an upper house inquiry into the recruitment process that saw him appointed the state’s Senior Trade and Investment Commissioner to the Americas.
He has since withdrawn from the $500,000-a-year role, which is based in New York.
Mr Barilaro told the inquiry he flagged his interest in the role to Premier Dominic Perrottet on a phone call in November after his resignation from cabinet, to which he claimed Mr Perrottet responded “great”.
Mr Barilaro said he spoke to then-trade minister Stuart Ayres and texted Treasurer Matt Kean about the role, too.
He told the inquiry he expected to clear his name and has refuted any suggestion he sought any special treatment.
LIVE UPDATES: Read our live blog as John Barilaro gives evidence
Mr Barilaro was asked about a briefing note sent to his office stating a candidate for the job, Jenny West, had been selected for the role in August 2021.
He said he didn’t recall seeing the note, but accepted it contained an electronic signature of his in accordance with a process in his office for when he was away.
Mr Barilaro said he had “no issue” with Ms West, who described him as a “strong professional”.
Ms West has previously given evidence to the inquiry that she was told on August 12 she was the successful candidate.
She claims that offer was later revoked and she was told the job would be a “present” for someone.
“I didn’t know that Jenny West was offered a contract … this inquiry has really opened that up,” Mr Barilaro said today.
He denied the government was seeking to create a bunch of “pork barrels” in changing the position to become a ministerial appointment.
“I will say this, if I knew what I know now, I wish I never had applied,” Mr Barilaro said.
“If I knew what I know now, I wouldn’t have walked into what was as**tshow.
“I’m going to use those terms, I’m sorry to say, because the trauma I’ve gone through over the past six to seven weeks has been significant.”
‘An error’ to offer Barilaro the job
In her third time answering questions before the inquiry, Investment NSW chief executive Amy Brown said that, “in hindsight”, it was an “an error” to offer Mr Barilaro the US job before a panel report was signed.
“The way these roles were set up as public service appointments, but with a high degree of ministerial interest, made it difficult to run an optimal process,” she said.
Ms Brown recalled hearing from Mr Barilaro in August 2021, when he recommended his then-senior-media-adviser, Jennifer Lugsdin, for an upcoming opening at Investment NSW.
Mr Barilaro and Ms Lugsdin are in a relationship, which did not commence while he was deputy premier, and Ms Brown said the only comment from him in that call about a relationship was regarding a professional one.
Ms Brown was presented with a chain of emails from December 2021 showing communication about the recruitment process for the US role.
The position was re-advertised publicly, on December 17, however the emails were sent about a week prior. The email chain was forwarded to Ms Lugsdin.
Ms Brown agreed it was a fair inference that Ms Lugsdin would have known by at least December 10 about a decision to commence advertising the role that year, “assuming she read that email”.
Elliott bows out of race for deputy Liberal leader
Meanwhile, the upper house inquiry’s terms will be extended to include other trade roles, after allegations Mr Perrottet offered to create a job for Transport Minister David Elliott.
This afternoon, Mr Elliott announced he would not run for the deputy leadership of the NSW Liberal Party after the resignation of Stuart Ayres from cabinet last week over “concerns” about his conduct in the appointment of Mr Barilaro.
Mr Elliot told Nine radio he would not contest the role, due to be determined on Tuesday, after a discussion with Mr Perrottet.
“I don’t think that’s going to be in the best interests of the party and I think it’s in Dominic’s best interests for us to have some unity for the parliament over the course of the next eight months as we go to an election,” he said.
Earlier today the Premier hosed down the job claims, telling Nine radio he had spoken to Mr Elliott about several roles — including NSW’s agent-general position in London — but that he was “never promised a job outside of politics”.
“That is deeply offensive and wrong,” the Premier said.
“But people always say, from time to time, discussions will be had in relation to when someone withdraws what they would like to do. That is normal.
“What I don’t do, as Premier, is say that I will ever make those appointments or offer anyone a job.”
Mr Perrottet said the conversations he had with ministers were private.
“I am not going to go into details in relation to parliamentary secretary roles or a role in the ministry,” he said.
He did not deny an allegation that Mr Elliott had requested to be made NSW governor if he retired.
“From time to time, members of parliament will always say to their colleagues what they would like to do after politics,” the Premier said.
“People come to me, or come to my colleagues and say, ‘When I leave parliament I’d like to do A, B, and C’.”
NSW Shadow Treasurer Daniel Mookhey said Mr Perrottet had many questions to answer.
“The allegations about the Premier allegedly offering David Elliott an appointment to the agent-general position in London are deeply serious,” Mr Mookhey said.
“Labor as a result will seek to expand the inquiry’s term of reference so we can examine the agent-general’s position as well as other roles across the world.”
The Premier said he would adopt the recommendations of a review into the hiring process for trade roles, which is due to be finished within days.
Treasurer Matt Kean confirmed he would run for the position of Deputy NSW Liberal Leader.
The Premier’s office has been contacted for comment.
NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet has commented on allegations he spoke about creating a highly paid public service role based in the UK for a minister.
Key points:
Dominic Perrottet said conversations about job roles with ministers were “private”
The Shadow Treasurer said Mr Perrottet has many questions to answer
John Barilaro is due to face questions today at the inquiry surrounding his appointment to a US trade role
Labor has sought to extend an inquiry into how former NSW deputy premier John Barilaro was appointed to a top US trade job, amid reports by Nine newspapers that the NSW Premier offered to create a new parliamentary trade role for Transport Minister David Elliott in London.
The report says the Premier spoke to Mr Elliott about the agent-general position in London as compensation following manoeuvres that could have seen him removed from cabinet.
Mr Perrottet told Nine radio this morning he discussed “a number of roles” with Mr Elliott, including the agent-general role in London, but the Premier stopped short of clarifying whether he spoke about creating a public service role for him.
“David Elliott was never promised a job outside of politics,” Mr Perrottet said.
“That is deeply offensive and wrong.”
“But people always say from time to time discussions will be had in relation to when someone withdraws what they would like to do. That is normal.
“What I don’t do as Premier is to say that I will ever make those appointments or offer anyone a job.”
Mr Perrottet said the conversations he had with ministers were private.
“I am not going to go into details in relation to parliamentary secretary roles or a role in the ministry,” he said.
Mr Barilaro is expected to face some serious questioning this morning when he appears for the first time before the inquiry.
The inquiry last week heard from senior NSW bureaucrat Kathrina Lo, who said she would never have signed off on her appointment as New York trade commissioner had she known of the level of ministerial involvement.
Trade minister and Member for Penrith Stuart Ayres resigned from his portfolios and leadership position in the party over concerns about his role in the selection process.
Mr Elliott did not directly respond to questions about the conversation with the Premier.
“I’m committed to delivering the NSW government’s infrastructure pipeline, which is helping transform our state, and ensuring our public transport delivers first-class services for the people of NSW,” he said in a statement.
“I have no interest in working overseas again.”
NSW Shadow Treasurer Daniel Mookhey said Mr Perrottet had many questions to answer.
“The allegations about the Premier allegedly offering David Elliott an appointment to the agent-general position in London are deeply serious,” Mr Mookhey said.
“Labor as a result will seek to expand the inquiry’s term of reference so we can examine the agent-general’s position as well as other roles across the world.”
The Premier’s office has been contacted for comment.
The New South Wales Minister for Small Business and Fair Trading, Eleni Petinos, has been sacked, plunging the State Government further into crisis.
Key points:
The Miranda MP was removed from cabinet by Premier Dominic Perrottet after his return from overseas
On Friday, Ms Petinos denied any wrongdoing after an anonymous complaint was made against her
It came from a staffer within her office, reportedly alleging bullying by Ms Petinos
The Premier has dumped the Miranda MP from state cabinet, a day after returning from an overseas trade trip.
On Friday, it was revealed an anonymous complaint had been made by a staffer from Ms Petinos’ office, reportedly alleging bullying.
The Minister denied any wrongdoing, releasing a statement saying “I reject any allegations of improper conduct”.
Speaking from India, the Premier confirmed an investigation had taken place into the complaint but he was satisfied with the outcome.
The Premier now says her position has become untenable.
“Today I spoke with the Minister for Small Business and Fair Trading Eleni Petinos after some further matters concerning her were brought to my attention,” the Premier said in a statement.
“In light of these matters, Ms Petinos’ service as a Minister will cease with immediate effect, and I will write to the Governor in this regard tomorrow.”
Ms Petinos was elevated to the Ministry in December last year, as one of three new Liberal women promoted to cabinet.
The Premier has now lost one of the seven Coalition women in his 26-person cabinet.
Her sacking comes as the Trade Minister, Stuart Ayres, has been under increasing pressure over the former Deputy Premier, John Barilaro’s appointment to a lucrative trade role in New York.
Documents released publicly to the parliament, have called into question his involvement in the recruitment process and whether he misled parliament.
Mr Ayres, who is also the deputy Liberal leader, maintains the process was conducted at arm’s length from Government and the Premier is standing by his Minister.
Ms Petinos has been the member for Miranda since 2015.
The Customer Service Minister, Victor Dominello, will take over her ministerial responsibilities.
“Tonight, the Premier informed me I would no longer be a Minister in his Government,” she said.
“I would never intentionally offend anyone or make them feel uncomfortable, and if I did I am truly sorry.”
She says she intends to stay on as the member for Miranda.
“I pursue politics to make a positive difference,” she said.
“I am proud of my work while I served the people of NSW as Minister for Small Business and Minister for Fair Trading.”