Categories
Sports

Canberra coach Ricky Stuart facing one-week suspension and $25,000 fine for ‘weak-gutted dog’ remark

Raiders coach Ricky Stuart has been hit with a week’s suspension and a $25,000 fine by the NRL after calling Panthers five-eighth Jaeman Salmon a “weak-gutted dog.”

The league has served Stuart with a breach notice, which he has accepted, with his seven-day suspension to take impact from 4pm on Tuesday.

It has also mandated that Stuart, not the Raiders, must pay the fine personally.

The decision marks the first time in NRL history that a coach has been suspended for comments at a press conference.

“The period of suspension prohibits Stuart from performing any duties as head coach of the Raiders, including attendance at team or individual training or coaching sessions or the Raiders’ facilities,” the NRL said in a statement.

“Furthermore, he cannot provide instruction or direction to the team, individual players or Club Officials during the period of suspension including before, during or after any matches within this period.”

This means Stuart will miss Canberra’s match against the Dragons on Sunday and will not return to the Raiders until next Tuesday.

NRL chief executive Andrew Abdo slammed Stuart’s comments, which are believed to have stemmed from an incident between Salmon and Stuart’s son when they were Under-12s teammates in 2010.

“Leaders need to set the standard in the game. The comments are completely unacceptable from any individual, let alone an official of such experience and standing,” Abdo said.

“This is a highly unusual case, and we have taken the significant step of proposing a suspension from his duties for one week.

“This will be a full suspension, precluding Ricky from having any involvement with any club activity, either in person or remotely.

“Furthermore, the fine must not be paid by the club but by Ricky himself.”

Earlier, Raiders chief executive Don Furner accepted that Stuart had done the wrong thing, and said it was important the club supported their long-time coach.

loading

“It’s just like waiting for a suspension of a player … we’ve said publicly that we’ll accept what punishment and what decision they hand down and then move on from there,” he told reporters.

“It’s a very public job and it’s a hard job. He’s obviously very disappointed and he’s embarrassed, and he’s just going to have to put it behind him and move on and we’ll all support him.”

Furner said he hadn’t discussed which assistant coach would step into the main role for Sunday’s game, but the former Raiders prop is tipped to take the role.

Canberra skipper Elliott Whitehead also went into bat for Stuart.

“We’ve got his back. He had his reasons,” Whitehead told reporters on Tuesday.

“I’m not going to go into them, but we’re all supportive of Ricky and he knows he probably shouldn’t have said it on that platform.

“He’s upset he let his emotions get the better of him.”

AAP/ABC

.

Categories
Sports

AFL: Lions star Lachie Neale lifting at business end of season

Lions ruckman Oscar McInerney has hailed the form of teammate Lachie Neale as Brisbane’s top-four hopes go on the line in the final two rounds of the regular season.

Currently in fifth spot on the AFL ladder but on the same points as third-placed Melbourne and fourth-placed Sydney, the Lions can guarantee themselves a top-four berth by beating St Kilda and the Demons in the next fortnight.

It’s a task easier said the done, but the form of star midfielder Neale will aid Brisbane’s top-four bid.

He was superb in the Lions’ weekend win over Carlton, with an all-round effort of 32 disposals, nine clearances and one goal moving him alongside Gold Coast Suns star Touk Miller at the top of the AFL Coaches Association’s MVP award.

Neale is also favored to win a second Brownlow Medal, having won the award for the first time in 2020.

“He’s gone up a level,” McInerney said in comparing Neale’s form from two years ago to now.

“We couldn’t be proud of that. He’s a phenomenal player.

“He’s the last guy out on the track, he’s always working on his touch, (doing) weights, he’s getting stronger, he’s fitter, he’s an incredible athlete, he’s got an incredible mindset… that’s a great role model for all our young players coming through.”

McInerney’s own form has been good but he is playing his performances down, claiming he just wants to keep things “nice and simple” for the likes on Neale and other Brisbane teammates.

“As long as I’m just jumping hard and creating a contest, we’ve got so many magical players like Lachie at the feet, they just do the rest,” McInerney.

“He (Neale) is just so clean. He just doesn’t fumble but that comes from the work behind the scenes.”

The Lions are attempting on producing a four-quarter performance when they head to Marvel Stadium for Friday night’s clash against the Saints.

Despite beating the Blues by 33 points at the Gabba last Sunday, Brisbane had a 57-point three-quarter lead which Carlton at one stage reduced to less than three goals in the final term before the hosts steadied to seal the victory.

“We’re still improving at this time of year, and I think that’s a really valuable thing for our team,” McInerney said.

“Obviously we need to cement that and go for longer periods, but it’s really pleasing and positive signs that we’re able to continue to improve.”

The versatile Callum Ah Chee will miss Friday’s match due to the AFL’s concussion protocols.

Defender Marcus Adams also didn’t train with the Brisbane team on Tuesday as he recovers from a sternum injury he suffered against Carlton.

Read related topics:Brisbane

.

Categories
Sports

Richie Mo’unga comes to terms with All Blacks pile-on: ‘It’s fair that the fans care’

All Blacks five-eighth Richie Mo’unga has a message for the New Zealand public. He gets your hurt, he understands your angst and he accepts your criticism – but, sorry, he’s too busy trying to help fix a broken team to dwell on it right now.

That was the gist of a heartfelt and emotional reflection from the 28-year-old, 36-test No 10 in Johannesburg on Monday as he let the barriers down in an impressive chat with the small New Zealand media contingent on tour with the team.

Of course, these are demanding, almost unprecedented, times for the All Blacks. Only four times in their 616-test history have they lost by more than the 16-point margin against the Springboks at Mbombela Stadium last Sunday (NZT), and it was their heaviest defeat in the republic in 94 years.

They are also on a three-test losing skid in 2022, and have dropped five of their last six internationals, dating back to last November’s loss in Dublin. They simply cannot take a trick right now, and appear to be stuck in a spiral of ineptitude. And their public have had enough, piling on the team, and especially their head coach, with toe-curling fervour.

It was a sobering time at Mbombela Stadium as the All Blacks reflected on a 26-10 defeat to South Africa.

Christiaan Kotze/Photosport

It was a sobering time at Mbombela Stadium as the All Blacks reflected on a 26-10 defeat to South Africa.

There is no respite on the horizon either, with the weekend’s Rugby Championship rematch against the world champion Springboks at their imposing Johannesburg fortress of Ellis Park. Not the place you want to play the South Africans when your confidence, form and rhythm is shot.

With that in mind, and Mo’unga poised to slot in as starting No 10 if there are any doubts around the neck injury sustained in Nelspruit by Beauden Barrett in a nasty mid-air collision with Kurt-Lee Arendse, the normally ebullient Cantab was asked how the All Blacks were handling the public reaction to their losing run.

“It’s part of it, but we’ve got younger guys in the group who haven’t experienced it at this level before, so it’s really tough on them,” he said at the team hotel in Sandton on a fine winter’s day. “It’s not just us, it’s our families. As someone who’s been there before and been around for a while, my mindset doesn’t change, my energy doesn’t change.

“I’m chomping at the bit to have another crack, but I’m also at the point where the outside noise doesn’t matter for me. It doesn’t affect me. I’m at a stage now if you’re not in our squad, I don’t really care what you think, with all respect.

“I understand the fans and people out there can get frustrated with results. But we’re trying our best, and we know it’s not good enough for All Blacks standards. So preparations will be very deep to get the result this weekend.”

Asked if he felt the criticism was fair, Mo’unga nodded slowly.

Richie Mo'unga has come off the bench in all four tests so far in 2022, but would love to get a starting crack this week.

Joe Allison/Getty Images

Richie Mo’unga has come off the bench in all four tests so far in 2022, but would love to get a starting crack this week.

“It’s very fair,” he replied. “A team they support that usually gets results is not getting results, and it’s fair the fans care. They care about our team and care about our results, but it’s also fair of us to not care about what they think because we have a job to do and hearing that isn’t going to help us.”

Later Mo’unga, who is clearly a conscientious fellow, reached out to clarify his comments about “not caring” what fans think. He meant to say they “weren’t bothered” by what people were saying.

Fair due. It’s an important distinction.

So, Ellis Park, with its devilish mix of altitude and attitude? Mo’unga has played there before, with the Crusaders, and at nearby Loftus Versfeld with the All Blacks. He has a fair idea what to expect.

“Nothing compares to it,” he says, as a smile breaks out. “For me this is the pinnacle. This is where you want to be playing against a team that is just awesome. There’s the noise, 60-odd thousand at altitude – you feel the blood in your lungs, you can taste it, and you understand the history. It’s a privilege to play at a place like that.”

Mo’unga is a little more guarded when it comes to any frustrations he may or may not have been feeling around his diminished status in these All Blacks. Since midway through last year he has ceded the regular starting No 10 spot to Barrett, and you just know the impact role off the bench doesn’t sit comfortably with him.

He hints at a burning desire to prove himself – and somehow disprove the notion he gets lost behind a struggling pack – but is careful to toe the team line.

“I wouldn’t say frustrated,” he says of four straight outings off the pine in ’22. “I’m the type of guy whatever role you give me in this team, I’ll do the best I can. But also I’m just ready. I’m capable of a start as well, I’m capable of being the guy, if the team needs me to be that guy.

“But I also understand if I have a role to come on for the last 20-30 to change a game around, I’m ready.”

Categories
Sports

Arthur’s classy response to fans who booed him

Jake Arthur’s second half against the Sea Eagles last Friday shows just how fickle rugby league can be because the Parramatta fans who were booing him last month would’ve been cheering as he helped up set a famous win on the road.

Filling in for the injured Mitch Moses, Arthur produced his best 40 minutes in the NRL and set up two tries to keep the club’s top-four hopes alive ahead of a brutal run to the finals.

The fact Arthur was able to do that after a small section of fans at CommBank Stadium had booed him only a few weeks earlier because his dad is the coach speaks volumes about the 19-year-old.

“I haven’t really worried about it,” he said.

“I’ve just waited for my opportunity and I’ve just been trying to play my best footy in Cup.

“It was just good to be able to wear that No.7. That’s where I feel most comfortable trying to control the game and letting Dyl (five-eighth Dylan Brown) play off the back of it.”

The first of those try assists against the Sea Eagles was a Harbor Bridge pass over the top of giant winger Jason Saab that some experienced halves wouldn’t have had the confidence to throw.

Eels teenager Jake Arthur throws a Harbor Bridge ball.Source: FOX SPORTS

“I was a bit worried because I told myself all week that I wasn’t going to throw that pass because he’s that tall,” he said.

“But in the moment I saw the space and I had to back myself to throw it.”

Teammate Shaun Lane spoke glowingly of Arthur’s maturity and how he handled himself after a difficult couple of weeks.

“I always chat to the young kids to see where their headspace is at around certain things, but I think Jake is quite a naturally resilient kid,” said Lane, who is studying a graduate diploma in psychology and faced his own problems off the field earlier in his career.

“I think it helps that his old man has helped along the way to understand what he probably would have faced ever since he was a kid.

“Growing up with his old man as the coach of Parramatta coming through the grades, he probably understood that he’d be facing a lot of scrutiny were this to happen.

“He’s definitely approached this maturely and I probably wouldn’t have been the same when I was that young.

“He’s stayed off social media, he hasn’t read into any of the negatives, and he’s gone about doing his job. I can’t speak highly enough of how he’s handled himself.”

Shaun Lane has been impressed by Arthur’s maturity. Picture; Cameron Spencer/Getty ImagesSource: Getty Images

Arthur’s reward for playing so well against Manly was an appearance on Channel Nine’s post-game show where he got to pick the brain of childhood hero Johnathan Thurston.

The former Cowboys halfback gave him some sage advice and adds to the lessons Arthur has learned from Immortal Andrew Johns as well as Moses.

“I’ve always looked up to ‘JT’ and studied how he played,” the teenage half said.

“It was good to be able to get the chance to speak with him and even ask for a bit of advice.

“I just wanted to ask him to see what I could do better. He told me to run the footy a bit more late in halves and to dig deep in the line once I’ve set up the game with my kicking game.

“I’ve always looked at ways to try to get better. Joey really helped me with that. He’s always ringing me and helping me out, and Mitch has also been massive for me since he got injured. All year he’s been helping me, and now he’s really stepped up.”

.

Categories
Sports

9/8/2022 Horse Racing Tips and Best Bets – Hawkesbury

Seven races will be run and won at Hawkesbury this Tuesday. The weather is fine, the track is good (4) and the rail is out two meters from the 1300m-1100m; Out four meters from the 1100m-450m; Out two meters from the 450m-Winning Post; True for the reminder.

*Existing customers only. 2nd Racing bet. Excl SA & WA. T’s & C’s apply. Gamble responsibly.

WATCH THESE RACES LIVE AT tab

RaceOne: 2 Inuwashi

RaceTwo: 5 Father’s Day

RaceThree: 5 Sir Ming

RaceFour: 4 Selfie Time

RaceFive: 5 Invincible Dash

Race Six: 2 Rome Avenue

Race Seven: 1 ceasefire

*Existing customers only. 2nd Racing bet. Excl SA & WA. T’s & C’s apply. Gamble responsibly.

BEST BET: Race One Number 2 Inuwashi

NEXT BEST: Race Two Number 5 Father’s Day

BEST VALUE: Race Five Number 5 Invincible Dash

Quaddie Tips (Races Four Through To Seven):

LegOne: 1, 2, 4, 6

LegTwo: 1, 2, 5, 8, 9

Leg Three: 1, 2, 4, 5

Leg Four: 1, 2, 4, 5, 9

$50 Investment = 12.50% of the dividend if successful

*Existing customers only. 2nd Racing bet. Excl SA & WA. T’s & C’s apply. Gamble responsibly.

Melbourne Cup winner Rogan Josh dies

Melbourne Cup winner Rogan Josh has died following colic-related complications. Rogan Josh was Bart Cummings’ 11th Melbourne Cup winner and had…

Australian Bookmaker Reviews

Which bookmaker should you bet with? We Review each of the leading online Australian Bookmakers and rate them in order…

Categories
Sports

Todd Payten, Johnathan Thurston, Face-to-face with Matty Johns, Cowboys, Tigers, 2005 grand finale

Watch Todd Payten on Face-to-face with Matty Johns on Tuesday night at 7.30pm on Fox League.

Cowboys coach Todd Payten revealed Johnathan Thurston originally didn’t want him at the club due to the fact he beat him in the 2005 Grand Final, while playing for the Tigers.

Payten’s Tigers beat Thurston’s Cowboys 30-16 in the 2005 decider and the future Immortal took the loss as hard as anyone on the night.

Stream every game of every round of the 2022 NRL Telstra Premiership Season Live & Ad-Break Free During Play on Kayo. New to Kayo? Start your free trial now >

However, even nearly 10 years later when Payten joined the Cowboys as an assistant, Thurston wasn’t interested in having a player who beat him in a grand final coaching at his club.

“A funny story he (Thurston) didn’t want me at the club,” Payten said on Face-to-face with Matty Johns.

“Obviously we had a history, Tigers vs. Cowboys in the 2005 Grand Final.

“Peter Parr brought it up with Johnno and he said, no way he is not at our club.

“In the end he had to be talked around and I’m grateful that they talked him around.”

MORE NRL NEWS

TEAMS ANALYSIS: Broncos’ backline shake-up; Knights recall enforcer

BANNED: NRL hand down Ricky ban as coach cops $25k fine for Salmon outburst

REVEALED: NRL’s punishment for Ricky for ugly spray as Kent slams

NEW ERA: Storm in ‘serious decline’ if Munster leaves as ‘biggest test’ looms

Johnathan Thurston was shattered after the Cowboys lost the 2005 decider.Source: News Limited

Johns asked if the rivalry between the Tigers and the Cowboys was that strong to last nearly a decade after the 2005 Grand Final.

“Was the rivalry that bitter?” Johns asked.

“No, it wasn’t bitter,” Payten said.

“It just typifies the type of competitor Johnno is. He doesn’t like to lose.

“I’d run across Johnno at different times in different places and he was always a decent fella to talk to, but losing grand finals is hard to get over.”

Get all the latest NRL news, highlights and analysis delivered straight to your inbox with Fox Sports Sportmail. Sign up now!!

Cowboys coach Todd Payten.Source: News Corp Australia

However, Thurston welcomed Payten to the club and they made two grand finals and won the 2015 decider together 10 years after that fateful 2005 match.

“It was enjoyable,” Payten said of coaching Thurston and the Cowboys of that era.

“I was a little bit gun shy with Johnno (Thurston) at first. He was one of the best players in the world and my thought process was, how am I going to tell him what to do?

Wests Tigers opt not to take legal action | 00:47

“But after a while he pulled me aside and said, mate tell me the truth, I want to know.

“That’s when I worked out that the elite players want to be coached and they want some information.

“He put me at ease with that.”

.

Categories
Sports

All Blacks vs Springboks news, Ian Foster, Kurt-Lee Arendse

Springboks winger Kurt-Lee Arendse has been banned four weeks for his dangerous collision with All Blacks five-eighth Beauden Barrett on Sunday.

Arendse clumsily challenged the airborne Barrett and the contact caused the Kiwi to flip spectacularly and land on his head and neck.

The South African was shown a red card by Australian referee Angus Gardner before being stretched off the Mbombela Stadium turf with a suspected concussion.

Watch every match of the Rugby Championship on the home of rugby, Stan Sport. Continue this weekend with Springboks vs All Blacks (Sunday 12.30am AEST) and Pumas vs Wallabies (Sunday 4.45am AEST). All matches streaming ad-free, live and on demand

The 26-year-old – playing his second Test as a replacement for injured superstar Cheslin Kolbe – had enjoyed an excellent game before that brain fade and scored the opening try of the 26-10 win to open the Rugby Championship.

Arendse pleaded guilty to what SANZAAR called a “reckless” and “highly dangerous” collision and will be sidelined until South Africa’s final game of the championship at home to Argentina.

Barrett was cleared of a serious neck injury but is in doubt for the re-match at Ellis Park on Sunday as the All Blacks attempt to snap a rare three-game losing streak.

READMORE: Golf battle turns ugly in fight for $25m prize

READMORE: Urgent plea after extraordinary Stuart outburst

READMORE: Aussies claim final Commonwealth Games gold

Under-siege New Zealand coach Ian Foster was afterwards seeingthing at South Africa’s aerial bombardment.

“Massive concerns,” Foster said regarding the Arendse-Barrett incident, before the suspension was handed out.

“It’s probably the worst I’ve seen. It was pretty disappointing because it happened in the 10th minute as well (to All Blacks fullback Jordie Barrett) and they deemed it was fair.

NEW PODCAST! Sean Maloney and Andrew Mehrtens couldn’t be happier that the Rugby Championship is underway with a win for the Wallabies in Argentina and a brutal battle in South Africa for the All Blacks

“Part of the problem in the game is in the lineout, if you throw a jumper over to their side with an arm up, it’s considered obstruction, whereas it’s becoming a free for all for jumpers just to be able to jump and stick a hand out and say they’re competing.

“It needs to be addressed.”

All Blacks halfback Aaron Smith admitted the tourists needed to deal better with the predictable but highly effective tactics.

“Our ability to defuse their bombs is something we need to fix,” Smith said.

“Their tactics there I think are a little bit borderline. To see Beaudy do a full flip is pretty scary. That’s a part of the game that needs to be looked at, but we’ve got to do a better job of protecting our jumpers Because, as we saw, we would stop them on defense around their 30m line and they would just put a bomb up – and it works for them.”

Richie Mo’unga will replace Barrett in Johannesburg if he is ruled out.

For a daily dose of the best of the breaking news and exclusive content from Wide World of Sports, subscribe to our newsletter by clicking here!

Categories
Sports

Fresh twist in Port Adelaide’s prison bar jumper debate as Collingwood makes bizarre teal strip offer

It is the great debate that has been labeled “ridiculous” by Geelong star Patrick Dangerfield, and it’s just taken another bizarre twist.

The lingering feud over Port Adelaide’s prison bar jumper has possibly – and certainly tentatively – moved forward with Collingwood prepared to offer the Power a minor concession, according to a News Corp report.

Watch Kochie blast Collingwood in the video above

Analysis, local footy and the biggest moments, Seven and 7plus are the home of footy shows for every fan. Stream them all for free on 7plus >>

The Magpies are reportedly prepared to let Port wear its prison bar jumper if the white stripes are replaced by teal stripes.

The historical Guernsey is worn by the Port Adelaide Magpies in the SANFL and used to be seen in the AFL during the national comp’s heritage round. However, the AFL has scrapped that round.

Port Adelaide will not be allowed to wear their prison bars jumper for the derby against Adelaide. Credit: AAP

Port Adelaide has since wanted to bring the jumper back into the AFL for the Showdown games against crosstown rival Adelaide but those requests have been met with staunch opposition from Collingwood who believe only their club should wear black and white stripes.

Dangerfield recently weighed into the debate, saying: “If we profess to be a national competition then… [that means] you have to acknowledge and understand the history.

“Being a national competition means we should acknowledge what those teams have done, even though it was in the SANFL (in Port Adelaide’s case), I think it’s still really important to acknowledge that history.”

According to reports, the clubs are due to discuss the issue but it is said that Collingwood will not budge from this latest teal bar offer.

Patrick Cripps set for AFL court over big bump.

Patrick Cripps set for AFL court over big bump.

.

Categories
Sports

NRL 2022: Adam Hills, Physical Disability Rugby League, World Cup, Australia

Physical Disability Rugby League pioneer Adam Hills is set to play against some of the team-mates he helped introduce to the game after being selected in an extended Australian squad for October’s World Cup in England.

Hills, who was awarded an OBE for services to Paralympic Sport and Disability Awareness in the Queen’s 2022 New Year’s Honors List, was instrumental in the establishment of a PDRL competition in Britain and has played for Warrington since 2018.

However, the comedian and TV host declared his allegiance to Australia on an episode of The Last Leg aired in the UK on July 29, which also featured an announcement of the draw for the PDRL World Cup.

The tournament will be played Warrington from October 23 to October 30 and features Australia, England, New Zealand and Wales.

A 40-man Australian squad was announced on Monday and will be reduced to 20 players on August 14, with Hills hoping to be among those selected for the World Cup.

“Honored to make the extended squad to represent Australia in the PDRL World Cup,” Hills tweeted. “Whether selected or not, I’ll do all I can to support the team.”


Adam Hills is a household name in Australia and England

Adam Hills is a household name in Australia and England
©RLWC2021


The majority of the squad played in a historic selection trial between the Gold Coast Titans and NSW PDRL teams at Cbus Super Stadium on July 16.

A fundraising campaign has been launched to assist with travel and other costs for the Australian PDRL team.

A household name in both Australia and England, where he hosts The Last Leg and Channel 4’s coverage of Super League, Hills is also a RLWC2021 ambassador.

After learning that there was a PDRL competition in Sydney, which included his beloved Rabbitohs, Hills offered to help Warrington establish a team.

Commuting from London to train and play, he has since played more than 20 matches for Warrington, two for Souths and represented NSW City and Lancashire.

A documentary Hills made about Warrington’s trip to Australia to play South Sydney in the Physical Disability World Club Challenge won an award in the Television/Digital Documentary category at the 2019 British Sports Journalism Awards.

Hills is now poised to pull on the green-and-gold jersey of Australia at the PDRL World Cup in England, which will be played alongside the Men’s, Women’s and Wheelchair tournaments.

The final of the PDRL World Cup will be the second match in a double-header with the Samoa v France game at Halliwell Jones Stadium on October 30.

Categories
Sports

Manase Fainu: NRL rising star ‘ended’ wild brawl with alleged stabbing

NRL rising star Manase Fainu did not start a bloody brawl in a church parking lot but he “ended it” when he plunged a steak knife into the back of a youth leader, a court has been told.

Mr Fainu, 24, is fighting allegations that he stabbed Faamanu Levi in ​​the back during a brawl outside a Mormon church dance nearly three years ago.

The Manly Sea Eagles hooker has pleaded not guilty to wounding a person with intent to cause grievous bodily harm after Mr Levi was stabbed in the back near his shoulder blade and cut above his right eye.

Mr Fainu’s trial has entered its final stages, with Crown prosecutor Emma Curran using closing submissions on Tuesday to point to the evidence of one eyewitness who told the court that he had seen Mr Fainu stab Mr Levi.

Mr Fainu during his evidence said he played no part in the brawl, which took place between two parked cars in a parking lot at the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints at Wattle Grove in Sydney’s southwest.

During his evidence on Monday, Mr Fainu said he was approximately 10 to 12m from the fight between his friends and another group of men when he heard someone yell “knife, knife”.

He had undergone shoulder surgery a month earlier and on October 25, 2019, he had his left arm in a sling.

Tony Quach said he saw Mr Fainu stab his friend Mr Levi and was able to identify him by his sling.

During his evidence, Mr Quach said Mr Fainu had not started the fight but “he ended it” by stabbing Mr Levi.

“Manase Fainu jumped over a fence into the grounds of the church, he was with four of his friends and the group of them approached Mr Levi and his friends,” Ms Curran said.

“A brawl broke out and when things looked like they were getting out of hand, Mr Fainu pulled out a knife and plunged it into the back of Mr Levi, causing a wound that punctured his lung and caused internal bleeding.”

Mr Quach said he saw Mr Fainu with an angry look on his face and a knife in his right hand and his arm bent at a 90-degree angle.

It is not an issue that Mr Fainu was in the car park, his left arm was in a sling, and there was a brawl during which Mr Levi was stabbed before Mr Fainu scaled the wall once again and ran to his car.

However, the identity of Mr Levi’s attacker is in dispute.

Ms Curran said another man, Kupi Toilalo, said he saw a man approach him and his friends with his left arm in a sling holding a knife.

“When Kupi saw this, he was at arm’s length away from the person holding the knife, nothing obstructing his view,” Ms Curran said

Mr Fainu told the jury on Monday that he was “scared” because he knew he could not defend himself if he became involved in the fight.

He denied brandishing a 10cm steak knife that was used to stab Mr Levi, saying he did not see any of his friends with a weapon on the night.

Mr Levi underwent surgery after the stab wound punctured his lung and caused internal bleeding.

Mr Fainu said he went to the church because his friend Uona “Big Buck” Faingaa was seeking to recover money owed to him by a man.

The court was told that before the brawl, two of Mr Fainu’s friends were involved in an altercation on the dance floor and were asked to leave.

Mr Fainu said he left the church grounds as his mates were being escorted out, apologizing to a security guard on the way out.

CCTV footage showed Mr Fainu and four of his friends shortly afterwards jumping a fence from a Coles carpark back onto the church grounds.

Mr Fainu testified that he had told his friends that he would go inside to collect Mr Faingaa’s money by himself; however, they followed him over.

Defense barrister Margaret Cunneen SC said Mr Fainu had been identified as being present during the brawl because of the distinguishing nature of his sling, but all of the eyewitnesses were mistaken about him being the stabber.

“Mr Manase Fainu is a man who was never before in trouble for any violence whatsoever,” Ms Cunneen said.

“He did not stab Mr Levi. No one condom what happened to Mr Levi, it’s appalling.”

The jury will withdraw to consider its verdict after Ms Cunneen’s closing submissions.

The trial before Judge Nanette Williams continues.

.