Michmutters

Despite opposition from Dominello and the council, the spokesman said the project was backed by members of the RSL and rugby clubs. “There exists significant support in the Ryde [local government area] for what is proposed and for the delivery of a new one-hectare public park.”

The spokesman also said the amount of open space per resident in Marsfield exceeded the rest of the Ryde council area and NSW government guidelines.

The rugby fields no longer served the Marsfield community, especially new residents from China, India, Korea and the Philippines “where rugby is not popular”, he said.

The viability of keeping the rugby fields had also been affected by previous council decisions rejecting lighting upgrades and imposing parking restrictions, he said.

“Despite the best efforts over many years of Eastwood Rugby and North Ryde RSL to keep TG Millner Field alive, the fields are unused and not relevant to the local community.”

The row over the future of the TG Millner Field follows a controversial deal by Lane Cove Council to allow the construction of senior housing on sporting fields in Lane Cove.

Dominello said public open space in Sydney was precious “and once it’s gone it’s gone forever”.

“That’s why we must fight to save TG Millner Field for future generations,” he said. “If proponents of the plan don’t think rugby is popular any more, then we should work together to accommodate other sports.”

loading

The TG Millner Field is the home ground for the Ryde-Eastwood Hawks rugby league club – although it only uses the ground on Sundays.

Football operations manager Michael Frain said the club could use the facility six days a week for 10 months a year if permitted.

Frain also said the club will not have a ground to play in the area if the project goes ahead. “There is not one rugby league field in Ryde [local government area] at present for training or playing, so there is an obvious need to keep green space.”

The planning proposal is currently being assessed by council officers, but 12 out of 13 Ryde councilors in June voted to oppose any plans to reduce green space in Ryde.

The councilors also voted in favor of a motion to secure the TG Millner Field, described as an “iconic local landmark”, as open space in perpetuity.

Ryde’s Major Liberal Jordan Lane said the Ryde area needed grounds for all sporting codes. “TG Millner is a premier field, worthy of preservation.”

Lane said there was “no doubt traffic and other social pressures will be exacerbated by the concurrent eroding of open space, and development of new dwellings”.

loading

The Ryde area needed 13 additional sports ovals by 2036 to keep up with demand and population growth, he said. “Decimating one of our largest existing open spaces will set this cause back significantly.”

Lane said it was “absurd” to suggest any part of Ryde had sufficient open space.

“Were the fields to be made available to the public, council could also help address the oversubscription of requests for its current sporting fields,” he said.

“When you’re talking about the size and scale of Lismore LGA alone, no council anywhere can afford to even partially fund that,” Krieg said.

Blocks of privately owned land had been identified on the outskirts of Lismore that could be used to permanently rehome flood-affected residents, Krieg said.

“There are people who have been sitting on some suitable land for a long time, saying that now is an opportunity to open that up,” Krieg said.

The council said in May that about 1,000 homes would need to be rebuilt off the floodplain, at a cost of $400 million.

The challenge with any buyback or land-swap scheme would be meeting demand, according to Resilient Lismore, a grassroots group helping with recovery.

“Lots of people are ready to go,” co-ordinator and Lismore city councilor Elly Bird said. “They’re just waiting to see what the government will deliver before they decide what they’ll do.

“We know Queensland moved very quickly with a program around buybacks and land swaps, and here we are, still waiting.

“We’d like to see that [independent inquiry] report. That’s our report, our submissions that we put in, and we want to see the results.”

Krieg also called on the government to release the report in its entirety, saying his community needed certainty after five months in limbo.

“People have been holding off making big decisions about their homes and their businesses, waiting for this report.”

loading

Labor state MP Janelle Saffin said purchase prices in a buyback scheme had to be based on pre-flood property valuations, a sentiment echoed by residents.

Schofield said many of the flood-affected parts of Lismore were low-socioeconomic areas and any buyback or land swap scheme had to ensure people had enough money to pay off their debts and start again.

”If you still have to pay your bank [exit] clause in the mortgage, buy a piece of land and build, that will be out of reach for I’d say 90 per cent of people in North and South Lismore.”

She is back living in two rooms of her home, but without any walls, and said she and her neighbors were frustrated waiting for details on what help would be coming their way.

loading

“A week when you’re living like this is a very long time. It’s incredibly stressful. A lot of people are really anxious about their futures.”

She would ideally like to take part in a land swap and move her house with her.

“A lot of us have beautiful old houses built 120 years ago and some of them are still in very good nick. And the community doesn’t necessarily want to separate from each other.

“If we had a magic wand, I think there’s a large percentage who would stay fairly close to where we are now, just out of the flood.”

The Morning Edition newsletter is our guide to the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up here.